MUNICIPAL CONSENT ORDERS


Overview

 

The Consensus Process
In April 2002, the municipal officials, engineers and solicitors of the ALCOSAN service area communities began negotiations with the Environmental Protection Agency, PA Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) and the Allegheny County Health Dept. (ACHD) regarding municipal consent orders for their sewage collection systems. Almost two years later in January 2004, nearly 100 percent of the municipalities signed consent orders that are feasible and cost-effective for the communities while also meeting the objectives of the regulatory agencies to comply with the Clean Water Act.

During those two years, 3 Rivers Wet Weather facilitated an extensive consensus-building process for the municipal representatives of the communities within the ALCOSAN service area through more than 150 meetings. Throughout this process, the municipal officials, solicitors and engineers worked together across municipal boundaries in an unprecedented manner.

Highlights of the process include:

  • February 2002: EPA proposes a non-traditional enforcement approach—municipal consent orders, one designed for combined sewer communities and another for separate sanitary communities—which do not include penalties for past and current violations of the Clean Water Act and the Clean Streams Law.
  • April 2002: DEP and ACHD distribute an initial draft of the consent orders. 3RWWDP initiates a consensus-building effort for the development of a more feasible and cost-effective version of the proposed consent orders.
  • August 2002: The municipalities submit to the agencies, proposed consensus-based draft orders.
  • May 2003: the regulatory agencies distribute another draft agreement to the ALCOSAN communities. 3RWWDP again initiates a consensus-building effort to continue the negotiations and work toward feasible consent orders.
  • Late October/November 2003: ACHD and DEP distributed final consent agreement documents to all 83 ALCOSAN communities with a signing deadline of January 31, 2004.
  • February 19, 2004: A Moving Forward 2004 event is held at the David L. Lawrence Convention Center to mark the region’s progress on the wet weather sewage overflow issue.

Consent Order Requirements
Under the municipal consent orders, the EPA assigned enforcement responsibility to the DEP and ACHD. Municipalities operating a combined sewer system (carrying wastewater and stormwater in the same set of pipes) received a “Consent Order and Agreement,” which is enforced by the DEP. Communities with a separate sanitary sewer system (wastewater and stormwater are transported in two separate systems) received an “Administrative Consent Order,” which is enforced by the ACHD. The orders span six years (2004-2010), and require communities to complete the following activities:

  • Assess and map the sewer collection system
  • Clean and televise the system
  • Make critical repairs
  • Conduct flow monitoring
  • Develop a long-term control plan in conjunction with ALCOSAN

For a specific timeline of required activities, click the appropriate order below:

 

Top

 
     
Improving our region's water quality